This list will have almost everything I saw in 2025 unless I really didn't care for it (both the plot and the acting/direction), and there were a few things like that unfortunately. I think I only left in the middle of David French's Leaving Home, but I probably should have bailed on Job (at Coal Mine) and Winter Solstice (though this was all in one act, making it hard to do.) However, I have cut back on the Fringe listings, focusing here on what stood out for me. I realize that isn't entirely consistent, but I just see so much at the Fringe most summers that I want to raise the bar that much more. Most of these plays will not be coming back to Toronto any time soon, but there may still be a few SPOILERS in my commentary on the plays.
Jan
Buddies/Common Boots - Last Landscape (an almost wordless piece that was much more about the movement and setting; not really my thing but some people liked it a lot)
Talk is Free Theatre - Cock (an intense piece in a constrained space with a tug-of-war between a straight woman and a gay man over a second man)
Factory - Small Gods: The Musical (a workshopped version of a queer musical set largely in a mall)
Talk is Free - For Both Resting and Breeding (an odd piece set in someone's kitchen in the far future when gender has all but been erased)
Canada Stage - Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf (another intense piece, somewhat undercut by one of the leads getting ill with his replacement not entirely off-book at that point; it probably would have worked better at the Berkeley Theatre in a less gargantuan space)
(I was supposed to see Shakespeare Bash'd The Merchant of Venice, but my performance was cancelled due to a freak blizzard and they weren't able to rebook me, which is supremely frustrating, even though this is not a play I actually enjoy...)
Feb.
Eldritch Theatre/Red Sandcastle - The Strange and Eerie Memoirs of Billy Wuthergloom
VideoCab - Cliff Cardinal's CBC Special
Coal Mine - People, Places & Things (depressing piece about a women finally kicking her addictions and her family being too burnt out to really care)
Canadian Stage - Fat Ham (retelling of Hamlet with a gay Hamlet who is in love with Laertes, probably the very hardest thing to believe was the Claudius character would prefer to die choking on food rather than allow Ham to perform the Heimlich maneuver. I found myself incredibly annoyed at the way lower middle class African-Americans were portrayed as so absurdly homophobic, and this was even more blatant in A Strange Loop, which I won't even list here, as I found this trope so offensive...)
Theatre Centre - Monks (brought back by popular demand from Fringe 2024. So odd, with a plot ostensibly about the two monks trying to find a lost donkey, including a lot of audience participation; I was glad not to have been picked.)
March
Outside the March - Performance Review (a play about the author's best and worst jobs, set in an actual coffee shop)
Crow's - Measure for Measure (basically a small troupe putting on a radio play version of Measure for Measure, with some implied side action between the actors going on)
Factory - Truck (basically about truck drivers being replaced by technology but it ends up also being about the rivalry between a union leader and an average guy driver)
Alumnae - Age of Arousal
Al Green Theatre - Cabaret
April
Theatre Centre - Red
Crow's - A Public Display of Affection (an older gay actor's memories of gay life in Toronto in his youth)
Canadian Stage - Mahabharata Pt 1 & 2
Video Cabaret - Pochsy IV: Unplugged
Tarragon - Feast (the ending was implausible and the dig at vegetarians at the Feast at the End of the World was frankly uncalled for)
May
Shakespeare Bash'd - George Etherege's The Man of Mode (staged reading)
Video Cabaret - Brecht's Three Penny Opera (student production)
June
EldritchTheatre/Red Sandcastle - Buster Canfield's Apocalyptic Miracle Show
Canadian Stage - Next Time I Die (staged reading)
Canadian Stage - You, Always by Erin Shields (a staged reading of a play going on the main stage in 2026)
July
It looks like the only theatre I did in July was Fringe, but there was a lot of it. Here are some of the best I saw this past summer: #1 Clown Show, Shady Arab Ladies, Jimmy Hogg: Potato King, A Canadian Explains Eurovision, The Rhinoceros Collective, The Adding Machine, Adam Bailey: My Three Deaths, Oh! I Miss the War, Mocktails on the Beach, The Perils of Being Born in the Fall, Stealing Home, Things My Dad Kept, The Sexy Pigeon Show and Milk Milk Lemonade.
The funniest show was Milk Milk Lemonade (edging out Jimmy Hogg: Potato King). I learned the most (actual facts) from The Perils of Being Born in the Fall. The best revival was surely The Adding Machine. The most touching was Things My Dad Kept.
Aug.
Canadian Stage - Shakespeare in High Park: Romeo & Juliet (Juliet and her father were very well acted, but I thought Romeo was rather weak and Tybalt was just terrible)
Summerworks - Le Concierge (an interactive piece where we walked all through a school following a custodian and even cleaning some windows by the end)
Summerworks - The Chains (another hyper-interactive piece where we eventually were sorted into groups (Team Creon, Team Antigone or the Chorus) to act out a production of Antigone!)
Summerworks - Leftover Market
Stratford - Macbeth (I liked Hamlet on motorcycles a lot better than most of the critics)
Stratford - The Winter's Tale (this is a play I simply hate, despite the fine cast, and will never see it again)
Stratford - Erin Shields's Ransacking Troy (very good but not nearly as comic overall as I had been led to expect)
Shakespeare in the Ruff @ Withrow Park - Tiff'ny of Athens (genderbent and time-shifting version of Timon of Athens; while I would like to see a proper production one of these days (I skipped out on one last year at the Theatre Centre), this actually gave me a pretty good feel for the piece)
Sept
Soulpepper - Harold Pinter's Old Times (this makes the third time I've seen this enigmatic play!)
Soulpepper - King Gilgamesh (I saw this before and decided at the very last minute to try to get rush tickets to see it a second time; it inspired me to actually read the Epic of Gilgamesh and this play is very faithful to the epic, which is pretty cool)
Crow's - Octet (this started strong but ended oddly, and I particularly thought the bit about the scientist (who used to heckle religious types just as Richard Dawkins did) encountering a godlike figure was inane and essentially ruined the piece for me)
Coal Mine - Beckett's Waiting for Godot (a fine performance, a bit more physical at some points than I was used to)
Oct.
Stratford - Goblins: Oedipus Rex (my second trip out to Stratford and the Goblins slayed)
Tarragon - Bremen Town
Talk is Free Theatre - David Harrower's Blackbird (really hard to take play about a pedophile who reunites with the woman he seduced when she was 13 or so!)
Nov.
Soulpepper - Jacobs-Jenkins's The Comeuppance (did not like the plot much at all, esp. the ending, but the acting was generally terrific)
George Brown @ Young Centre - Ruhl's Orlando
Crow's Kanika Ambrose's The Christmas Market (an interesting, often depressing, peek into the lives of the temporary foreign workers who keep Canadian agribusiness humming along)
Canadian Stage - Robert LePage's Far Side of the Moon (I saw this years ago in Vancouver with LePage in the role (!), but he wasn't performing this time around; the spectacle is good but the plot is wafer-thin and not really at all memorable)
Coal Mine - Fulfillment Centre (my main beef with this play is that the finance has uprooted her life and yet seems to have no feelings at all for her partner, and maybe even more to the point, two of the characters have extremely troubled lives but the root cause seems personal and not due to the pressures of capitalism, which is what one would have expected from this play; I thought the ending was incredibly weak)
EldritchTheatre/Red Sandcastle - Little Library of the Damned
Icarus @ Theatre Centre - Dennis Kelly's DNA (dark comedy about teens more or less re-enacting Lord of the Flies but in an English suburb)
Shakespeare Bash'd - Middleton's Women Beware Women (staged reading)
Alumnae Theatre - New Ideas Festival Week 2 (some good short pieces here with the standout piece about two women talking in a doctor's office before one woman is about to get news if she has cancer)
Dec
Factory Theatre - Public Consumption (this conveyed the horrors of the internet much more effectively than Job, which I felt was too gimmicky)
RedOne Collective - The Dishwashers by Morris Panych (the very welcome return of RedOne Collective, this play is staged in an actual restaurant; while I didn't care for the very last scene, overall this was quite good)
Soulpepper/Bad Hats - Narnia (a fun musical for all ages)
Crow's - Michael Healey's Rogers v. Rogers (a one-man show with Ted Rogers and his wife and children all played by one actor, going into the details of the Rogers' takeover of Shaw Communications)
I saw roughly 80 plays, musicals or staged readings in 2025, which is not shabby considering reviewing isn't actually my profession.
The best spectacle was The Mahabharata Pt 1 & 2 at Canadian Stage. I did find that nearly all the plays had something that kept them from being truly amazing, often some annoying wrinkle in the plot that didn't hold up very well. Looking over the whole list, I think probably the best play was Ransacking Troy at Stratford, followed by Rogers v. Rogers at Crow's and then Goblins: Oedipus. However, Measure for Measure essentially done as a radio play (@ Crow's) was very good. Red at Theatre Centre was also quite good, though it suffers a bit from the fact I've seen it several times before, including on Broadway!
I was heartened by the return of RedOne Collective, as well as a new company starting up called Icarus Theatre. And I didn't go to all their shows (as I just am not that interested in Tracy Letts's Bug), but King Black Box is another up and coming company that I need to keep an eye on. For the most part, the best payoffs of the year were from these smaller theatres or events at Fringe and Summerworks.
But to me the best news of all is that Toronto Cold Reads started up in a new incarnation in Dec., and they have accepted my Stratford piece for either Jan. or Feb. So that is exciting and gives me more motivation to keep working on my own creative writing!
I will say that given the somewhat lukewarm or hostile reception I gave to some of the critical darlings of the season (especially The Welkin), I am starting to rethink how much theatre I really ought to go to, as I don't seem to enjoy it as much as I used to. Or maybe I am just feeling bruised at the very high ticket prices of most of these shows (and indeed there were a few shows I decided just weren't worth the $60+ ticket prices) when I often have mixed feelings about the experience.
One thing that stood out to me is that playwrights who decided to use their soapbox to engage in "both sideism" really lost me, and I lost all respect for what they were trying to do. This was only a fairly small element of Feast where there was some completely decadent Feast for the End of Time where all kinds of endangered species were being eaten by these rich, nihilistic assholes, but somehow the author had to claim that vegetarians would also be there eating rare, ancient grains. It's such a stupid attempt to knock vegetarians and vegans off their moral high ground (as not eating meat (at the levels indulged in by western societies) is objectively better for the health of the planet than eating (so much) meat). But this is only a very minor (sour) note in a fairly long (too long) play. The bit about the anti-religious zealots (like Dawkins) being just as toxic on the internet (as believers of various persuasions) might have some validity, but the way it was introduced in Octet is far from ideal. Having the scientist dropped into a lengthy scenario where he encounters a godlike being that his scientific rationality can't explain (and thus he is forced to admit he might have been wrong in the past) is beyond stupid and really made me dislike the whole piece.














